I saw Precious this evening. I had debated about seeing it, since I already knew I would have a negative reaction to it. But since I wanted to properly critique it, I needed to watch the film for myself.
I will give Precious two things: fantastic acting and great cinematography.
What I did not like about this film:
-It literally degrades the black American family. Please come and film a movie about my life, or another average black person. I do understand that these stories exist, but this could of been literally any poor person's story, but it becomes a "black thing."
-The film causes you to hate the mother. Of course, but what about Precious' father? We never see his face, and so the film places the blame onto the mother- when in reality the rape was never her fault.
-As I watched it, I couldn't help but think of how during slavery masters and much of white America viewed black women as poor mothers because a few African women has thrown their children into the water when they were taken into bondage on slave ships. This film was degrading to black motherhood.
-Much too graphic. There are other ways of getting a violent point across.
-The incest thing really bothers me, because, and I'll be frank- it's not a black thing. I'm not saying that obesity and poverty are, but incest, that's not something that happens much in the black community compared to in others...
-And I'll stay on that topic for a few more minutes, why is it permissible that the incest is part of this film, but was never even alluded to in Divine Secrets of the Ya-Ya Sisterhood, when it was part of the book? Can we not "see" white actresses like Ashley Judd in roles like that?
-I hate that some of our schools do not provide the necessary means for students to thrive. I am frustrated with the disparities.
So, there we go- just a few of my thoughts on this.











